Call us: (07) 5530 2860
Select Page
Egg salad

Why Do Doctors Know So Little About Food

I am a doctor and everything I know about food that is worth knowing, I learnt somewhere other than medical school. We learn so much in medical school, much of it bizarre and obscure and rarely used in real life. But when it comes to food, which we ingest every day, which serves as the building blocks of our body, and is often the cause of our illness and disease, we seem happy to skip over that.

Have you ever wondered why this is the cause?

Let food by thy medicine and medicine be thy food.

In ancient times, physicians understood the importance of food, and even used it in medicinal ways. The quote: “Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food” is widely attributed to Hippocrates, who is considered by many to be the Father of Medicine. Yet over time, as modern medicine has become more adept at fixing what ails us, we have become less and less inclined to look at what may be making us sick in the first place… the way we live, including what we eat and drink.

Food as medicine is not just ancient history… it is increasingly being shown that illness and disease are largely lifestyle related, and yet still we are reluctant to educate our patients in how to live, including how and what to eat, as part of our duty of medical care, perhaps in part because we know little about it, as we have been poorly educated ourselves, and we are still unwilling to look at food when it comes to our own eating habits.

As doctors, we learn very little about food and nutrition during our training, and we rely on the (often outdated) advice of dietitians, to whom we hand over the reins and the responsibility when it comes to advising our patients about what and how to eat and drink.

Why have we allowed this?

Why do we think that we don’t need to know about food as medicine and that it is someone else’s job?

We have now reached the rediculous state of affairs where doctors are being professionally censured when they have dared to offer dietary advice, as in the case of Dr Gary Fettke (1), who has been forbidden from talking to his patients about food.

Doctors love food

Many of us consider ourselves as connoisseurs of food and eating it is often the highlight of our days. Yet we are also surprisingly ignorant about the nutritional values of food and the caloric consequences, and are willing to eat whatever to fuel ourselves to keep going and do what we think we need to do… we eat hospital food, fast food, junk food, frozen meals from the supermarket instead of fresh, wholesome food… why the contradiction?

We do what we do for a reason… so if we are doing something that apparently makes no sense, it is always good to look a little deeper until we can see the reason underlying it.

What do we use food for?

For myself, I used food (2) as a reward, as a treat… I was willing to do whatever it took during the day, and work hard for long hours, as long as I could reward myself with food at lunchtime, at the end of the day, and on my days ‘off’. My personal go-to was sugar, in its many and varied forms, but we each have our own thing, be it savoury, sweet or spicy, hot chips, potato crisps, pasta, chocolate, cake, or whatever.

I also used food to numb myself, if I was feeling uncomfortable and didn’t want to feel like that… carbs work best for that, which would be great if they did not make you fat and if those pesky emotions did not keep bubbling up anyway, requiring more and more carbs to push them down!

If I was feeling a little sad, dairy did the trick, either sweet, as in ice-cream or chocolate, or savoury, as in anything with cheese, would do… but my lungs and sinuses started clogging up, and my nose would run during the day and I would snore at night.

And I would override my perpetual exhaustion with sugar and coffee. The problem with that, is the short upper would be followed by a downer, requiring more uppers to bring me back up, and by the end of the day I was so tired and wired that I would need alcohol to pick me up, and then some more to bring me back down enough to get a fitful, because I was exhausted, sleep.

Waking still exhausted the next morning and having to get up and go to work anyway required more coffee and sugar and carbs. And so the cycle continued and escalated.

How can we turn this cycle around, and eat in a way that sustains and truly nourishes us? Foe me, that change came with the understanding of the true purpose of food.

What purpose does food serve?

We use food for stimulation, distraction, numbing, reward and treats, but the true purpose of food is to sustain and nourish us, to provide a body that is light and vital and can support us through the day, without eating in a way that interferes with that light and clear and energised feeling.

Rather than flitting from one diet to the next and trying to find our way through the minefield of contradictory data and advice about food, the simplest thing is to learn to listen to our bodies and let them guide us through life. Not our tastebuds, which can be distracted and stimulated and would have us eating all sorts of things we should not, but our whole bodies!

My husband and I call it the warm and yummy diet. We eat things that make us feel warm and yummy inside, and leave us feeling clear and light and vital, and we let go of the things that don’t. There is a simplicity and a lovely honesty to eating and living this way.

By following the warm and yummy diet – with no perfection, for our tastebuds and our eyes still lead us astray at times and we can still just be pigheaded and decide we want something anyway, even though we know how it is going to affect us – I no longer drink alcohol or caffeine, I eat very little carbs (an apple or a handful of nuts rather than loads of bread, pasta, rice, cakes, biscuits and potatoes as I used to), green leafy vegetables, and salads, some nuts and seeds, and loads od herbs and spices and… that’s about it.

I know, it sounds daunting, but this has been a gradual change over many years, and it has happened not because I thought I should or because I followed someone else’s advice, but because I became willing to listen to my overweight, dull, listless and exhausted body and to start to treat it with tender loving care.

The most astonishing thing for me was when I finally stopped eating gluten, most reluctantly, because it was making me fall asleep at work after lunch and in the car. I realised how much it was numbing my body and preventing me from feeling anything much at all.

From then on, when on the way home, my body became much more sensitive and I was able to feel how each food and drink was affecting me and make changes accordingly. Our food now is actually very delicious and satisfying. We entertain regularly, and our friends who eat ‘normal’ food love coming to eat with us and don’t feel like they are missing out on anything when they share the food we eat.

We are constantly refining what we eat according to where our bodies are at. If a food makes us feel congested, or bloated, or tired, or whatever, we look at whether we should still be eating it, and make changes accordingly… eventually, depending on how attached we are to it!

And if we are attached, we ask ourselves why… what does that particular food do for us, and why are we so unwilling to let it go, when our bodies are clearly telling us that it no longer serves us.

As Socrates said:

Thou sholdst eat to live; not live to eat.

Are we willing to reframe how we see food, instead of turning a blind eye to it so we can continue to indulge ourselves and use food to not deal with how we are feeling? If we can make that commitment, we will truly be rewarded, not the temporary reward of a mouthful of something that is transient and followed by the consequences that our body has to deal with, but the true reward of feeling delicious in our bodies, every single day.

We will feel light, energised, vital, and more able to do what we want and need to do. And we will serve as true role models, for our family, friends, staff, colleagues and patients, of how to eat and live in a loving way that sustains us.

If we let food be our medicine, and learn to eat to live, listening to the wisdom of our bodies, and letting them guide us through life, we will be honouring the true purpose of food, which is to fuel our bodies to be fit for life, and we can serve as a true and loving inspiration for others. Now that is true medicine.

By Dr Anne Malatt – Opthalmologist Bangalow NSW

Unimed Living